Saturday, February 3, 2007

2/3 readings

I really enjoyed reading this week’s readings. The articles were informational and really got me thinking. I think it was interesting to really see how technology shapes our lives today. The article that I enjoyed the most was “Children Online: Learning in a virtual community of practice”. As I read the article I was brought back to my undergrad education classes where we were told that children learn best in environments where they feel comfortable, and that when they are comfortable learning would come natural. That we need to create classrooms and lessons that were student led where students were so engaged that they wouldn’t know the difference between having fun and learning. The community that the children in the article created was just that. They created a world, on their own, that had rules, standards, problem-solving, and decision making, all without being told to. They were all equals, they learned from each other and were not restricted by having to follow a certain criteria. No one was telling them what to do, how to do it, or telling them they were wrong. If something they attempted to do didn’t, work, it was ok. They just tried something else or did it another way. The children were comfortable because they were working with a topic they had a high interest in with a media they were comfortable and familiar with. From that, they were able to take risks without worrying about whether or not they were correct or what would happen if they were wrong. That is the type of risk taking teachers try to persuade students to do. I think the problem with the way it is done in school is that it is done with media students are not necessarily interested or comfortable with. Students view the computer and internet more as a toy than a tool and are therefore more comfortable using it. Some teachers on the other hand are not as comfortable using computers as their students and are afraid to utilize it. I think some teachers feel that these programs are too hands off, that they do not have enough say in the directions that they go. I think teachers need to practice what they preach and take risks in these non-traditional exciting new programs. I’m sure we will be pleasantly pleased in the results.
The article I liked the least was “Zero to Six Electronic Media in the Lives of Infants, Toddlers and Preschoolers” I thought that a lot of the findings were obvious. I also think that we need to look at the circumstances that surround these findings. Parents today are very different from those in the past. Fewer mothers are staying home to raise their children. Many parents are juggling parenting and working and do not have as much time to really sit down with their kids. Not only that, we now have more single parent households than in the past. Many parents do rely on television and videos as a “babysitter” so that they can get things done. I don’t see this as a bad thing especially when they are educational. What I think we need to keep in mind is that these things should not be used as a replacement, but as a supplement to reinforce skills we try to teach our kids but may not have the time to fully do ourselves. I do agree with the article in that we should monitor and set limits on the amount of time children spend exposed to these things. Children’s lives at this age are almost entirely dictated by their parents. It is up to parents to balance out children’s lives to make sure there is a balance in their exposure to all aspects of life. It is up to the parents to make sure that children have time to spend outdoors away from the television and be with other children. Giving them this exposure allows them to practice real life interactions they witness in some of these videos.
I enjoyed reading the other article, “What Next? Toddler Netizens, Playstation Thumb”. I liked how it pointed out how each generation has thought that new medias would cause children to become lazy if they use it. I think that it is a big eye-opener for us. A lot of people today claim that computers and video-games have caused children to become lazy and can no longer think for themselves. That computers do so much that children can not problem solve for themselves anymore. They do not realize that children are problem solving when they use these medias. They have to choose what they think will work best to help complete their tasks. If children didn’t have to think to use these things, they everyone would be able to do them. What we need to do if find ways to utilize these things the way our predecessors have. The creation of books did not cause people to stop using their minds. It actually did the opposite. Books have expanded our thinking. Just like books helped expand our minds and thinking, computers have too. Children are able to find things easier than before because they are more accessible. Children are more likely to look up words they don’t understand when they use a computer because it is so much easier to access. They do not need to look things up in a dictionary. Many times all they have to do is click on a word. Without this media children are more likely to ignore words or concepts they don’t understand.
These three articles remind teachers that we are moving into a technological world and we need to embrace it and not fight it.

2 comments:

Fabulous at Fifty said...

I am so happy to have read your take on the articles, because it lets me know that I am on the right track. You said so many things that I agreed with. One being, I too, liked "Zero to Six" the least.

While, "Children Online" talked about children working collaboratively, I wish I could get my special needs kids to work together in groups. Many of them are so immature and have so many emotional issues that just getting them to do any work is a feat. If I could channel what they know about navigating technology into academic success, I would feel more like I've taught them something. But as I said in my assessment, most of my kids use technology to entertain themselves, not to assist them with their academic success. Although, I have had students that are quite familiar with Tolkien's Lord of the Rings Trilogy and I find that amazing because Tolkien developed a whole new language around those books.

Fabulous at Fifty said...

I am so happy to have read your take on the articles, because it lets me know that I am on the right track. You said so many things that I agreed with. One being, I too, like Zero to Six the least.

My problem with Children Online is, I wish I could get my special needs kids to work together in groups. Many of them are so immature and have so many emotional issues that just getting them to do any work is a feat. If I could channel what they know about navigating technology into academic success, I would feel more like I've taught them something. But as I said in my assessment, most of my kids use technology to entertain themselves, not to assist them with their academic success. Although, I have had students that are quite familiar with Tolkien's Lord of the Rings Trilogy and I find that amazing because Tolkien developed a whole new language around those books.